Struggling lawyers aren't weak — they're unprepared

How gaps between expectations, systems and support create predictable challenges for both lawyers and firms 

Most lawyers who struggle at work are not struggling because they are not good enough. 

 

Some do not realise they are struggling until they are told it’s time to leave.  

 

This often happens because nobody has shown them how the environment actually works — and they are trying to succeed in a system they were never properly prepared for. The gap between what is expected and what is experienced is where the seeds of problems are sown, particularly early in a career.  

 

That is also why aspects of professional life can feel like a lottery — both for firms and the people who work there. 

 

For firms, that shows up as:  

  • historic approaches to managing performance no longer working  

  • supervisors who are technically excellent but struggle to manage people  

  • issues becoming expensive because they were not addressed early  

  • loss of talent, often linked to specific teams or individuals  

  • intergenerational challenges - inconsistency in how people experience the firm’s values 

  • struggling to keep pace with rising behavioural expectations  

 

For individual lawyers, it shows up as:  

  • navigating a gap between expectations and reality  

  • struggling to judge whether something is a minor issue or is more serious  

  • difficulty distinguishing between professional stretch and overload  

  • navigating different expectations across supervisors  

  • getting pulled into avoidable negative spirals  

  • feeling they have less control than they actually do  

  • realising too late that they have drifted off track  

 

These are not easy issues to navigate, and they are not always openly discussed — even though their effects are widely felt.  

 

Law firms are exceptional at developing technical expertise. They are less consistent at equipping people for the complex realities they face.  

 

We know this because we have lived it — as lawyers, as senior HR professionals, and as the people firms call when something has already gone wrong.  

 

The gap between technical excellence and the ability to manage people, pressure and careers has consequences.  

 

Those consequences tend to fall first on the individual carrying the weight, then on the supervisor who was never properly equipped, and eventually on the firm — often through performance, people and risk issues.  

 

That gap is closeable,  but not by accident.  

 

It will not be closed through interventions that are not grounded in the practical realities of law. It requires clear insight, the right tools, and support that helps people navigate the pivotal moments that shape outcomes.  

 

That is why Arrisan exists. 

Want to find out more?