When Procrastination Looks Profitable – Part 1: The Individual
“You may delay, but time will not, and lost time is never found again.” Benjamin Franklin
The alarm you’ve learned to ignore
Last week the electricity in my house went off.
After several hours an electrician traced the problem to crossed wires and the power returned. The burglar alarm was particularly happy about this and celebrated in the only way it knows how — with a deafening racket. Did my neighbours rush to help? Of course not.
When an alarm goes off on your street the reaction is universal. People register it briefly and carry on. Experience has taught them it almost certainly means nothing. A device invented to trigger urgent action has become background noise.
It’s somewhat different when it is your own home. The siren cannot be ignored. It crosses the line from something irrelevant to something you must deal with immediately.
Many lawyers live with a distant alarm running somewhere in their lives.
It might be a conversation they have been putting off, an opinion they dread seeking, a high-stakes opportunity that is easy to defer, or the uncomfortable truth that the career they are building is neither fulfilling nor sustainable, however good it looks to others. The signal is there. But it is surprisingly easy to treat it as background noise. That pattern sits at the heart of procrastination.
Procrastination isn’t a productivity problem
Many procrastinating lawyers do not resemble the stereotype. They are far too busy for that. Can you really be procrastinating while recording 2,000+ hours a year? Yes. Easily.
Busyness is great camouflage.
The popular image of procrastination is someone avoiding work by scrolling through emails, tidying a desk, getting a coffee etc. Basically, doing anything except the thing they need to be doing. In professional environments the signs are rarely that obvious.
Procrastination often wears very respectable clothes. It looks like thoroughness. It sounds like prudence. It feels like waiting for conditions to be right. Underneath these behaviours sits something deeper than self-management: self-protection.
The delay is our response to perceived threat. It protects us from situations that might risk exposure, criticism or failure. As Socrates observed, “By the work you know the worker.” Or, as one someone I reported to once told me, “You’re only as good as your last piece of work.” Really? If you accept to idea that countless acts of delivery count for nothing, the self-esteem stakes are terrifyingly high.
When our personal worth becomes bound up with our performance, a mistake feels like a verdict: this sentance has a typo. It is rubbish: Therefore I am rubbish.
Like perfectionism, attempting something and falling short feels like much more than a professional setback. Delay offers the promise of safety. If the attempt is never fully made, we can always tell ourselves: I could have done it if I had really tried.
The immediate reward is relief. The risk has been postponed, perhaps indefinitely. But at the price of shrinking our confidence in ourselves to break new ground and handle setbacks.
That trade — short-term relief in return for a longer-term cost — is one of the most consistent patterns behind unhappy careers in law.
Why lawyers are particularly exposed
Law attracts people who have, by and large, not failed much. And if they have, many have taken it very personally in their determination never to do so again.
It is a knowledge industry, and it selects for academic excellence. A history of achievement becomes part of professional identity. It is also where a particular form of vulnerability can begin. When your sense of self has been built on being top of the class, putting that record at risk can feel dangerous. Failure begins to feel less like part of learning and more like an existential crisis.
Law firm culture can encourage this unhelpful way of thinking. Take the six-minute time recording unit.
When I was starting out, I thought the idea was to always try to be productive and efficient. I was wrong.
One of my supervisors reprimanded me: “Will you slow down? Don’t be a post-box.” The official message from the top was to keep the client happy. Depending on who you worked for, the message on the ground was sometimes different: keep the client profitable, even if that meant taking longer than necessary.
I ignored the advice for several reasons, one of them being that I was already working 60 hour weeks and had no interest in dragging things out for longer than necessary. But the moment revealed something about the signals it is easy to absorb, especially early in a career.
In many firms busyness equals value. Keep your hours up or prepare to be uncomfortable. We are not happy when we have too much work, and we are not happy when we have too little. Either way, have the common sense to appear busy.
This can encourage a strange incentive.
The lawyer who steps in at the eleventh hour to resolve a crisis often gets the superhero cape. It is visible and it takes more time. The person who noticed the early warning signs and prevented the problem entirely tends to go unremarked. It is harder to spot and does not show up as heroically high hours.
When last minute intervention is rewarded and prevention is invisible, the lesson absorbed by everyone watching is simple: delay repays. Quiet efficiency does not pay.
This is one form of profitable procrastination.
Another form stems from our training to look at problems with the objective of working out who is right. Lawyers really like being 'right', and this can lead us to waste time dwelling on the reasons why something is not working for us, allocating responsibility and talking about what 'should' be done by others. None of that helps us work out how to make the situation we are in work better for us and to take action into our own hands.
Stories that keep us stuck
I remember little about the day I was admitted as a solicitor. I had not been getting much sleep at the time. I do remember the exchange with the President of the Law Society at the certificate-giving ceremony.
He could have said congratulations. He could have asked why I had left his firm on qualification. Instead he asked a different question.
“Are you busy?”
“Yes.”
“Good. Good.”
My internal response was less enthusiastic. I knew I would be working until at least midnight the next day as the price for attending the ceremony.
Like the British talking about the weather, in law firm land many conversations start with empty exchanges about how busy we are. But busyness is worth talking about more deeply. It is one of the most socially endorsed forms of avoidance available to professionals. What else are we avoiding, beyond feeling bad about ourselves?
Procrastination is rarely about the work itself. We meet deadlines. We deliver no matter what. Quite often, we are crowding out dealing with the things that matter most. A career conversation that never quite happens. A difficult discussion with a colleague. A question about health, relationships, direction, or the life we are building outside the office. These issues do not compete well with the intensity of work. They wait. And the inbox is relentless enough to ensure they keep waiting.
To make putting it off feel reasonable, we tell ourselves stories.
“I just need to get through this busy period.”
“There is a right moment to act, and this is not it.”
“There’s nothing I can do about it at the moment and it’s the same everywhere anyway.”
“It’ll get better when I’m more senior.”
“Committing fully and falling short is worse than not committing at all.”
If similar thoughts have passed through your mind recently, it is worth asking what sits on the other side of them. If there's the sound of a distant alarm, it is likely a matter of when, not if, you'll have to face it. Why not turn some of that incredible drive you possess to get ahead of the issue?
The cost of profitable procrastination
The immediate benefit of procrastination is obvious: discomfort is postponed. The longer-term costs are harder to notice because they accumulate gradually.
Research links chronic procrastination to stress, disrupted sleep and reduced engagement with the behaviours that lead to a healthy life and a happy career. The change is rarely dramatic. People simply adjust to a "less than" life and decide to treat that level as normal. Opportunities pass. The odds of fulfilment lengthen, despite trying to fill the gap with short-term morale boosters.
The professional costs often remain hidden for years.
Procrastination can function tolerably well in the early stages of a legal career, when the focus is on technical competence and law firm economics are on your side. As you get more senior, however, things change. Expectations change, and judgement, delegation and quick decision-making under scrutiny become more important. At that point procrastination becomes far less functional, far more visible and much more damaging to others. When decisions are weighed down by worry, creative thinking shrinks. Anxiety rises.
The relational costs tend to take a while to appear and are often the hardest to reverse. Questions about health, relationships and the direction of your life continue to fall off the agenda because they are not someone else’s emergency. So they wait, until eventually they confront you.
A different way of approaching it
The beliefs that sustain procrastination sound reasonable. They reinforce caution and caution reinforces delay. The cycle can persist for years without being named. External performance often looks fine, and lawyers excel at presenting cogent arguments for why things have to be the way they are.
Breaking the pattern rarely happens through a single insight. It usually begins with a gradual shift in perspective: recognising that the standards being applied may be harsher than the situation requires, that the quality of a piece of work is not the same as the value of the person producing it, and that postponing decisions does not remove their consequences.
The first step is usually small. A conversation that has been avoided. A question finally asked. A step taken toward the issue that has been circling in the background.
Very often what you fear never happens. Fear has a habit of making the wolf appear larger than it is.
Practical takeaways for individuals
Listen for the alarm. What important issue has slipped into the background because you have become used to the noise?
Ask what you are protecting. When you delay something that matters, what judgement are you trying to avoid?
Examine your busyness. How is constant activity serving you? What might surface if you slowed down?
Stop waiting for the perfect moment. The right moment is usually a fiction. A smaller step taken earlier is almost always more useful.
Start small. An exploratory conversation, a scribbled note, or a single question can start the ball rolling.
Look ahead honestly. Consider the lives of people further along the path you are on. Not their status, but their lives and how content they are. Is that direction the one you want?
Part 2: The firm version
The patterns described here do not only affect individuals.
Professional environments can reinforce them. Certain behaviours are rewarded. Certain problems are easier to ignore. Delay can sometimes produce short-term advantages.
In other words, profitable procrastination does not only operate at the individual level.
The second part of this article looks at the same pattern from the other side of the system: how firms themselves defer issues, why that happens, and what it costs when the alarm goes unheeded.
Because for organisations, just as for people, the cost of delay rarely gets written off.
It accumulates.